CountriesIndonesia
Indonesia
A value-chain study chose corn and poultry, horticulture and fisheries, named six bottlenecks, and ranked eleven projects by bankability and impact.
Indonesia: three food chains, eleven projects
This is the method at work on one country. With the government, the study chose three food chains, followed each from production to export, named what holds it back, and ended in a ranked list of projects that can be financed.
13 insights that concern Indonesia
What the study found
Two farm sectors
Large plantations, run by the state or by private investors, grow export crops such as palm oil and rubber. Small farmers grow rice, soybeans, corn, fruit and vegetables by traditional methods.
Why these three chains
Corn and poultry serve self-sufficiency, and feed ties them together. Fisheries lead the country’s food exports, and demand for fruit and vegetables is rising.
What holds growth back
Outdated infrastructure and limited access to capital. Small landholdings and limits on foreign investment have kept private money out of farming.
Fisheries under strain
Most production is farmed, with seaweed in the lead. Some waters are overfished while others are underused, enforcement against illegal fishing is weak, and fishers lack the scale and skills for sustainable management.
Six areas to fix
Supply of raw material, knowledge and innovation, manufacturing capability, logistics and transport, people, and finance.
Where it can get to
More value from the same resources: sustainable farming and fishing, storage and logistics that link farm to factory, and a processing industry renewed by technology that replaces imported inputs.
The projects
- Finance for small producersCapital for rural banks that serve small farmers and fishers.
- FisheriesCold storage, traceability for pelagic fish and shrimp, modern shrimp farming, and more carrageenan made at home.
- Corn and poultryMore farm machinery made locally, silos, better irrigation for corn, and a more efficient poultry sector.
- HorticultureResearch and innovation to raise output, and sustainable control of pests and disease.
One of the value-chain studies behind the partnership strategies our team led.
Indonesia: a food hub that has to turn green
Indonesia is the world’s largest producer of palm oil and its third-largest producer of rice, and its farms are among the most productive of the countries we studied. What holds it back is small scale outside palm oil, thin finance for small farmers, and the cost to its forests.
What the study found
Strong at the farm gate, weaker in the factory
In palm oil Indonesia is strong from the plantation to trade and first processing. In rice, meat and fish it mostly grows and consumes at home. Second-stage processing, where more of the value sits, is still thin.
Two farm sectors in one country
Private companies manage a little over half of the palm land. Smallholders work most of the rest and sell to the large players. Rice is the opposite: small farms and small mills.
Money reaches the large, not the small
Banks lend to companies with steady income and collateral. Most small farmers have neither, and depend on microloans. Foreign investment in the sector has stalled, and only a few industries, such as palm oil and fish farming, attract it.
Skills are the weak point
Infrastructure is fairly advanced, and the state funds local makers of farm machinery. Education lags: curricula are dated and access to higher education is unequal.
Palm oil carries the environmental bill
Deforestation, single-crop planting and soil loss weigh on the whole sector’s record, while buyers ask more and more where a product comes from.
Where it can get to
A varied food hub for Asia: strong in staples and in higher-value products such as fish, palm oil, rice, coffee and cocoa, processing far more of them at home, with the loss of forest and soil stopped and production certified to international standards.
Where to act
- Stop the damage firstEnd deforestation, single-crop planting and soil erosion. Set clear standards for palm oil and let an independent body check planting and production.
- Back new methodsSet up an innovation agency and a research hub for smart farming, and give targeted grants to agri-tech start-ups that solve sustainability problems.
- Train the workforceTrain farmers and processors to adopt the new technology.
- Sell what buyers pay more forOrganic and traceable products earn a premium from processors and customers in developed markets.
One of the country assessments in the industry studies produced by our team.
Insights that concern Indonesia
13 insights
Indonesia: the nickel ban that built nine smelters
Indonesia stopped exporting nickel ore. It lost about 30,000 mining jobs and gained nine smelters and 17,500 more skilled ones.25%of the world’s nickel is mined in IndonesiaFinanceIndonesiaZakat and waqf: giving that is hard to put to work
The money is given. The difficulty is moving it into projects. Endowment property stays undeveloped for lack of capital.InsightFinanceIndonesiaIndonesia: insurance that grows fast and still misses the poorest
Sharia-compliant life insurance in Indonesia grew 26% a year, twice as fast as conventional cover. Most people still cannot afford it.26%yearly growth in Sharia-compliant life insuranceAgri-foodIndonesia and 2 morePalm oil: the value sits in the second processing
The countries studied produce 87% of the world’s palm oil. More than half the value is added at a stage they hardly own.87%of the world’s palm oil comes from the countries studiedFinanceBangladesh and 3 moreMobile money: the cheapest handset is enough
A mobile money service in Bangladesh handles more than 5 million transactions a day. It runs on the simplest phone.5 milliontransactions a day on one service in BangladeshMining and PetrochemicalsGuinea and 3 moreAluminium: the ore is worth a tenth of the metal
The world’s bauxite market is worth about US$17 billion. The aluminium made from it is worth US$180 billion.30%of the world’s bauxite reservesAgri-foodIndonesia and 3 moreRice: more grain from half the water
Flooded rice fields use 30 to 45% of the world’s fresh water. Drip irrigation raised yields by 29% with half the water.30–45%of the world’s fresh water goes to flooded rice fieldsAgri-foodIndonesia and BangladeshFish: farms overtake the open sea
Fish farming has grown from a quarter to nearly half of the world’s fish in two decades. Indonesia is the world’s second producer.18%of the world’s fish comes from the countries studiedTextiles and PetrochemicalsIndonesia and 3 moreMan-made fibre: the fibre that prices the others
The countries studied make 7% of the world’s man-made fibre. Five of them make 96% of that.7%of the world’s man-made fibreMiningTurkey and 4 moreCement: West Africa uses a quarter of the world average
A person in West Africa uses about 120 kilograms of cement a year. The world average is 520.120 kgof cement a person a year in West AfricaMining and FinanceBurkina Faso and 2 moreGold: widely mined, high in value and dug by hand
The countries studied mine about a fifth of the world’s gold. Much of it is dug by small miners who use mercury.21%of the world’s mined goldPetrochemicalsSaudi Arabia and 2 moreBase chemicals: 70% of the value comes later
The countries studied make a fifth of the world’s base chemicals. The second processing, which they do less of, adds 70% of the value.20%of the world’s base chemical productionPetrochemicals and Agri-foodMalaysia and IndonesiaDetergents made from palm oil
The countries studied hold up to 40% of the world’s capacity for plant-based chemical ingredients. Detergents are moving that way.40%of the world’s capacity for plant-based ingredients, at mostNo insight matches these choices.