InsightsInsight

The smile curve: making the product is the step that pays least.

⅔of world trade, about, runs through value chains
9.9%of Africa’s economy is manufacturing, down from 12.8%

Figures from the source, rounded.

About two thirds of world trade now runs through chains in which goods cross several borders. Along such a chain the returns are uneven. Research, design and purchasing at one end, and distribution, marketing and services at the other, earn more than the factory in the middle.

What the work found

Where the countries stand

All of the countries studied are still at the bottom of the curve, and most have not yet reached the level of production.

How others moved

South Korea, Taiwan and Japan coordinated their policies to move from production into design and research. The United States and some European countries moved into marketing and services while adding research and design.

Out of industry too early

Mature industries moved offshore bring low-income jobs with little value added. A country diversifies and stays in the middle-income trap. In Africa, manufacturing fell from 12.8% to 9.9% of the economy in twenty years.

Policy made by industry misses

Chains are organised by process, and trade rules are written by industry. One regional free-trade area that set out to be a hub for textiles and clothing ended up diverting trade.

What it calls for

  1. Enter at the bottom, with a plan to climbJoining at the production stage creates unskilled and semi-skilled jobs. Upgrading follows as skills, the business environment and links between industries grow together.
  2. Look outwardBase industrial policy on how the country connects to a chain, and specialise where it already has an advantage, instead of spreading into new industries.
  3. Align the state and the firmsThe disconnect between public policy and what firms do is named as the main cause of failure.

From our team’s published work on value chains and development.

Try a country, an industry or a word such as solar, cotton or fund.