InsightsInsight

Upgrade or deepen: two different jobs for industrial policy.

2kinds of intervention: upgrading and deepening
3tests to choose the value chain
5steps to study it on the ground

Figures from the source, rounded.

Industrial policy often treats every promoted sector alike. The method separates two cases. Where a country already sells a product competitively, the hard infrastructure is usually there, and what the product needs is skills, education and research. Where a whole industry adds much value and has many links to the rest of the economy, it needs support across the industry.

What the work found

Upgrading

Close the gaps to move into more complex products driven by science, technology and innovation. The gains: being first, better investment, and growth that lasts and includes more people.

Deepening

Close the gaps to move into products of higher value added with strong links backward and forward. The gains: productivity, income and better jobs.

Soft or hard

Upgrading works through soft interventions such as skills, education and research. Deepening works through hard ones that lift a whole industry.

Five steps on the ground

Assess and validate the chain, map it, analyse its activities and performance, identify constraints and opportunities, and define the interventions.

They can swap

The two kinds are interchangeable, depending on what the analysis on the ground finds.

What it calls for

  1. Choose by evidenceA product index points to upgrading. Indices of value added and of industry strength point to deepening.
  2. Check it with those who do the workThe chain is mapped in consultation with the people in it.

From our team’s published work on value chains and development.

Try a country, an industry or a word such as solar, cotton or fund.